Oct. 10, 2011: Bond markets closed; prepayments & FHA/VA loans; new mortgage company; U.S. economy treading water
Rob Chrisman
At
this week’s MBA conference in Chicago I have noticed conference
participants doing their very best to look very busy, even when
standing in a lobby, by staring at blackberry screens and
squinting at name tags. There is no indication that mortgage
bankers, thankfully, will be participating in races with
artillery, worth two minutes to see just how zany British
Sailors are: http://biggeekdad.com/2010/09/manly-men/.
Don’t try this at home with the kids.
While
the data last week seemed to ease fears of the US economy
slipping back into a recession, European concerns remain
paramount and all eyes will be on developments coming out of
meetings over the weekend and this week on the handling of
Greece's debt problems. But face it: this issue is going to be
with us for a long time. The
Treasury/bond market is closed today - so anyone sending out a
rate sheet will price "accordingly" (read: conservatively)
since they have no MBS prices in the U.S. upon which to base
their rates.
Friday’s
positive
employment (or at least not too negative) report capped off a
string of better-than-expected economic data, sending 10-year
Treasuries to the highest yield close in three weeks. It appears
that we’re not charging back into a recession, but on the other
hands the economy is not doing well enough to push rates too
high. Mortgage prices should be helped with the Fed’s new
purchase plan, relative to Treasury prices, but many, including
Paul Jacob of Banc of
Manhattan, suggest that bonds are linked pretty closely to
stock market performance at this point. “So we can fuss and fume
about the economy and the Fed – but if the Dow goes to 12,000
we’re looking at higher yields, and at Dow 10,000 the rally’s
back on - period.”
Prepayment
speeds came out last week, and they showed a big increase.
Every loan officer across the nation can tell you why: the
reduction of conforming loan limits starting October 1.
September was the last month where some of these high loan size
borrowers, whose loans would no longer be considered conforming,
could have refinanced back into an agency loan. I am sure that
low rates figure in somewhere, but rates have been pretty good
for quite some time. And
new borrowers seem to be the only ones who can have their
loans approved under recent guideline changes, so the newer
loans are the ones reaping the benefits.
Rates
are staying low, and many believe will go lower still, given the
state of the economy. But as mortgage rates have improved,
investors have increasingly become concerned about these jumps
in prepayments on lower coupon, recently originated mortgages.
However, due to the increase in annual FHA insurance premiums,
these concerns have predominantly been restricted to Fannie and
Freddie MBS. But what
about prepayments on FHA & VA loans impacting Ginnie Mae
securities? A look at rate sheets show that the FHA rate
being offered by originators is now 25-50 basis points lower
than the conventional rate. The increase in annual insurance
premiums only impacts FHA prepays. Prepayments on non-FHA loans
are likely to be faster than speeds at the end of last year.
Analysts point out that the impact of the net tangible benefit
test fades as the loan seasons, and that in fact the most recent
HUD outlook report showed that FHA-to-FHA refinancing
applications jumped by 70% and that delinquencies on 2009-2010
vintage Ginnies have been increasing over the last couple of
months. All of this adds up to many investors believing that FHA
& VA loans will start to prepay at a faster rate. Uh oh.
In
a related e-mail from a veteran loan agent: “I was able to
provide great deals to my FHA clients on the streamline program
even with the 5% rule. Let's face it: if you don't have at
least a 5% savings, it is not worth the cost to refi. Too many
lenders refi loans that really don't make sense to refi. The
old rule of thumb was that you must recoup the cost with savings
within 2 years, and I don't earn more than 1-1.5 points on a
loan. I was able to lower their rates and cover all the closing
costs. But the killer is the new PMI. Now, it is impossible to
streamline. In my opinion, they should go back to the lower PMI
or at least on the streamline redo at the same PMI rate as the
original loan – that will save borrowers a lot of money. Where
are all these people in the CFPB that are supposed to be
watching out for the consumer? They are busy redoing
forms.”
Is
delinquency in the eyes of the beholder? Not only are credit
unions reviewing their fee structure, hoping to pick off
depositors & clients from the big banks who are raising
their fees, but now NCUA will review the way it asks credit
unions to track modified mortgages after some credit unions
complained the current policy almost makes foreclosing the
troubled loans the more practical option. In other words, “Do modified payments mean
the loan is current?”http://www.cutimes.com/2011/10/06/ncua-to-review-controversial-mortgage-tracking-pol
We've
all learned how long it can take for a bill to pass Congress and
be signed by the president. A bill has been introduced
to allow struggling homeowners to withdraw funds from their
retirement accounts tax-free to make mortgage payments.
The Home Act (that name’s never been used?) would allow
borrowers to withdraw up to $50,000 from a retirement account or
one-half of the current value of that account, whichever is
smaller. The limit is a lifetime cap, and borrowers would be
able to make multiple withdrawals until they reach the cap; the
money must be used to pay on their mortgage within 120 days of
withdrawal.
The MBA is among the
industry groups calling on Congress to "do no harm" to the
fragile housing market. It is closely watching the
deficit-reduction super committee, which has targeted
homeownership tax breaks such as the mortgage interest
deduction and the capital gains exemption, Bloomberg
reports. Moreover,
the MBA continues to oppose efforts by regulators to impose
minimum standards for mortgage borrowers, such as a 20% down
payment, out of concern that such a move would not lower default
rates but would prevent many home buyers from obtaining loans.
Did the folks at Fannie know about "robo-signing" eight years
ago? It is alleged that it knew about allegations of improper
foreclosure practices by law firms in 2003 but did not act to
stop them. An unnamed shareholder warned Fannie Mae of alleged
foreclosure abuses in 2003, the inspector general for the agency
that regulates Fannie said in a report: http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Govt-report-Fannie-knew-of-apf-3965362442.html?x0§opStories&pos1&asset&ccode.
There
are indeed new mortgage banks being formed. Bexil Corporation has
agreed with the John Robbins Group to develop Bexil American
Mortgage Inc., a new mortgage origination company that
will focus on the wholesale and retail market. Many folks know
Mr. Robbins from his days as CEO of American Mortgage Network
and past Chairman of the Mortgage Bankers Association. In the PR
piece John Robbins, now president of Bexil American Mortgage,
said, "This is a perfect time to build a new nationwide mortgage
bank. I have always felt real opportunity is born in the vacuum
created by the bottom of a cycle. While many lenders are busy
dealing with problems arising from a deep housing slump, we have
the opportunity to create a nimble, efficient company not
burdened with legacy loan repurchase issues.”
If you ever want to see what the Fed is up to with its new
program of buying more mortgage-backed securities, go to: http://www.newyorkfed.org/markets/ambs/
Friday’s bank closures only had two on the roster: in Minnesota
the RiverBank’s depositors now see Central Bank on their
statements. And down in Missouri Sun Security Bank wasn’t secure
enough and is now part of Great Southern Bank as part of the
agreement.
Fifth
Third
got the word out to clients that for conventional loans, “Fannie
Mae (DU) loans with an LTV > 80% now only require a 3%
minimum borrower contribution from the borrower’s own funds for
1 unit primary residences only. (High balance product not
permitted, and MI requirements must be met of course.) Freddie
Mac (LP) loans will continue to require a 5% minimum borrower
contribution from the borrower’s own funds for mortgages with an
LTV > 80%.
Things quiet down this week, economic news-wise. Today's a holiday for
many, certainly for bonds in the US. Tomorrow we'll have
the FOMC minutes, Wednesday the MBA app numbers. Thursday things
"hot up" a little with Jobless Claims and some trade balance
numbers. Friday we have Retail Sales for September, import &
export prices, and a University of Michigan Sentiment number.
Really, aside from the FOMC minutes and Retail Sales, it is a
pretty ho-hum week.
An eye witness account from New York City, on a cold day in
December, some years ago: A little boy, about 10-years-old, was
standing before a shoe store on the roadway, barefooted, peering
through the window, and shivering with cold.
A lady approached the young boy and said, “My, but you're in
such deep thought staring in that window!”
“I was asking God to give me a pair of shoes,” was the boy's
reply.
The lady took him by the hand, went into the store, and asked
the clerk to get half a dozen pairs of socks for the boy. She
then asked if he could give her a basin of water and a towel. He
quickly brought them to her.
She took the little fellow to the back part of the store and,
removing her gloves, knelt down, washed his little feet, and
dried them with the towel.
By this time, the clerk had returned with the socks. Placing a
pair upon the boy's feet, she purchased him a pair of shoes.
She tied up the remaining pairs of socks and gave them to him.
She patted him on the head and said, “No doubt, you will be more
comfortable now.”
As she turned to go, the astonished kid caught her by the hand,
and looking up into her face, with tears in his eyes, asked her,
“Are you God's wife?”
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at