But in comments that moved one grizzled vet to write to me saying, “I hope Ed DeMarco runs for office – I’d vote for him!” the acting FHFA Director effectively nixed the idea of broad-based principal forgiveness by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. He cited three key factors in the analysis. The first was the NPV impact to taxpayer: the Treasury incentive payments would be considered as an offset to the NPV benefits of a principal reduction modification. The second was regarding borrower incentives, and the moral hazard issue associated with principal forgiveness: less than 1 million of the 11 million underwater borrowers would benefit from forgiveness, so what about keeping the remaining borrowers current on their mortgages, most of whom have always been current? Would the remaining herd be motivated to claim hardship or go delinquent on their mortgage? And lastly, the operational costs could escalate. Forgiveness guidelines would have to be clearly rolled out to over 1,000 servicers and that there would be costs associated with such a rollout. What about the costs of the HARP?

That all being said, DeMarco expressed a clear preference for forbearance over forgiveness, and indicated that forbearance is effectively a shared appreciation mortgage, with far fewer operational complexities than an explicit shared appreciation mortgage. Remember that it is no small deal: F&F have more than 465,000 seriously delinquent loans they own or guarantee. And the whole issue springs from a Treasury Department proposal to pay F&F as much as 63 cents for every dollar of principal they forgive. The Treasury would provide the money to the government-sponsored lenders from HARP 2.0 and leftover funds from the Troubled Asset Relief Program. In a January analysis sent to Congress, FHFA said it would cost Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac an additional $100 billion to write down all 3 million underwater loans to the value of the homes securing them. How about we use the money to plain ol’ reduce our deficit? For the text of his speech one can visit http://www.fhfa.gov/webfiles/23876/Brookings_Institution_Principal_Forgiveness.pdf.

"Rob, it is curious to note, given the recent claims against the two Franklin Bank executives in Houston, that Lew Ranieri was the chairman of Franklin's board. It will be interesting to see if "the father of mortgage-backed securities" is involved in this at some level, since it was under his watch that this took place: http://www.reuters.com/article/2008/11/13/us-franklinbank-bankruptcy-idUSTRE4AC4JI20081113."

I received this note regarding UG’s parent AIG. "One thing that readers should know is that the best estimate is that AIG, owner of UG, still 'owes' the government about $45 billion and the government still owns about 70% of AIG's stock.  Because the government converted much of its stake into equity, it will exit via stock sales when AIG exceeds $29 per share.  The balance of the government's investment is via a special fund organized by the Fed.  Those of us in the MI business know that the U.S. is happy just to get its money back but repayment isn't generating any private equity-like returns to the government.  It is also worth remembering that the U.S. consistently liberalized the repayment terms to ensure that AIG could repay.  It is amazing how quickly folks forget what happened."

How 'bout the CFPB determining the rules for mortgage servicers - what impact might these new proposed rules have on them? Well, here is the "borrower friendly" scheme that has been proposed: http://www.consumerfinance.gov/pressreleases/consumer-financial-protection-bureau-outlines-borrower-friendly-approach-to-mortgage-servicing/. And here is Fitch's opinion: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/10/idUSWNA465620120410.

The MBA reported what lock desks around the country already knew: applications dropped a little last week (2.4%) with refi’s falling about 3% and purchase apps down less than 1%. And for any LO who has their business model built around refi’s, the news is not good: the refinance share of total mortgage activity eased for the eighth week in a row to 70.5% of applications from 71.2% the week before. It was the lowest refinance share since late July, the MBA said. Hey, it can’t last forever, right?

How about some investor/lender updates from the last few weeks? As always, it is best to read the actual investor bulletins – information provided here is meant to show trends rather than timely detailed specifics.

Yes, outcry can actually change FHA’s underwriting changes! GMAC and other investors notified clients that the FHA is delaying the effective date of the following topics from ML 2012-03: Handling of Disputed Accounts, Public Records FHA Total User Guide Chapter 2, and Handbook 4155.1 4.C.2.e, Paying off Collections and Judgments. The new effective date of this section is delayed until July 1, but the FHA intends to seek additional input on this section and work to clarify guidance, as appropriate.

And a clarification on HARP 2.0, Interbank "was unlimited but since Wells Fargo changed to 105/110% we did the same thing weeks ago."

Wells Fargo wholesale has announced that, as of two days ago the 9th, it was implementing additional validations on lender-paid loans during the Receiving process so as to catch discrepancies between the GFE and loan application early.  Under-disclosed total broker compensation is highlighted as one of the most common incongruities, along with discount points, premium pricing, lender off-set credit, and loan amounts that don’t match up. Lenders submitting Right to Cancel forms are reminded to complete the form correctly or risk having their loan funding delayed or having to start a new loan.  Changes not initialed by the borrower, accidental borrower signatures in the “Cancellation Request” box, and dates that are changed such that they don’t reflect an accurate three-day recission period are all errors that should be avoided.

The guidance on flip transactions that Wells released on March 5th has been revised.  Sales of established non-profits that with a minimum two-year history as an affordable housing provider; are based in Philadelphia, Atlanta, Denver, or Santa Ana; and are included on the FHA Non-Profit List are exempt from the flip policy, as are previously allowed transactions shown as Credit Policy prior to March 12, 2012.  These transactions are eligible in addition to those outlined in the earlier communication. Happy Massachusetts Patriots Day for April 16th!  As an observed holiday in the Bay State, the 16th will not be considered a business day by Wells for Right of Recission purposes.

Fifth Third has issued updated guidance on values permitted through the collateral review.  For Freddie and Fannie loans where the desk review value is lower but sufficient for the transaction, the value should be upgraded to the field review value.  If the Desk Review value remains the same or increases, the appraised value should be used.  Portfolio products should use the Desk Review value in cases where it is either lower or higher; if it remains the same the appraisal value should be used.

Flagstar is revising the qualifying ratios it requires for loans to receive an “Approve” response from RD’s Guaranteed Underwriting System (GUS).  The maximum housing payment to income ratio will be reduced to 35.99%; the total debt to income ratio, 47.99%.  Loans with improper housing payment to income and total debt to income ratios will not be approved by the GUS. Some clarification on property inspections for streamline refinance transactions: a new appraisal isn’t necessary, but an inspection certifying that the property meets current HUD standards is.  Flagstar recommends having an FHA appraiser do the inspection. Warehouse customers at Flagstar are reminded that the minimum credit score for all government loan products has increased to 640 for loans locked on or after March 20th and that loans for borrowers with scores between 620 and 639 must now have been locked (the deadline passed on March 29th) and should disburse on or before May 11th.

Tomorrow the MBA will be offering a class titled, “The Historic Federal-State Servicing Settlement, Part II: Servicer Perspectives on Emerging Servicing Standards.” It goes from 3-4:30PM EST, online. “Learn how servicers who were not a part of the settlement are reacting to the servicing standards and how the settlement has provided clarity or more confusion to servicer roles, responsibilities and requirements. Hear from servicing veterans as well as a seasoned attorney who participated in the settlement negotiations. The cost is $50 for MBA members and $500 for nonmembers. (No, I didn't leave off a decimal - membership has its privileges.) Check it out: http://store.mortgagebankers.org/ProductDetail.aspx?product_codeâ121716AH%2fREGIS.

Anyone waiting to lock until yesterday afternoon reaped the benefits. In spite of slightly-above-normal MBS sales volumes, agency prices did very well relative to Treasury prices. There is still demand for production! The market was helped at 11AM PST by a good $32 billion 3-yr note auction by the Treasury. The increase in bond prices (and the corresponding drop in yields) was attributed to “risk aversion on continued euro zone and global growth worries, along with nervousness as Q1 earnings season gets underway after the equity markets close.” 10-year notes improved by about .5, falling below 2% for the first time in a month, and current coupon MBS prices ended better by .125-.250.

For today, we’ve had a couple minor numbers. (Export Prices, for example, were +.8% for March.) Later we’ll grapple with a $21 billion 10-yr T-note auction and the release of the Fed’s Beige Book at 2PM EST. In the early going the 10-yr’s yield crept back up to 2.03% and mortgage prices are a shade worse – but originators may see a slight improvement depending on where certain investors priced yesterday afternoon.


This student received 0% on this exam. Or should he have received 100%?
Q1. In which battle did Napoleon die?
* his last battle
Q2. Where was the Declaration of Independence signed?
* at the bottom of the page
Q3. River Ravi flows in which state?
* liquid
Q4. What is the main reason for divorce?
* marriage
Q5. What is the main reason for failure?
* exams
Q6. What can you never eat for breakfast?
* Lunch & dinner
Q7. What looks like half an apple?
* The other half
Q8. If you throw a red stone into the blue sea what it will become?
* It will simply become wet.
Q9. How can a man go eight days without sleeping?
* No problem, he sleeps at night.
Q10. How can you lift an elephant with one hand?
* You will never find an elephant that has only one hand.
Q11. If you had three apples and four oranges in one hand and four apples and three oranges in other hand, what would you have?
* Very large hands.
Q12. If it took eight men ten hours to build a wall, how long would it take four men to build it?
* No time at all, the wall is already built.
Q13. How can u drop a raw egg onto a concrete floor without cracking it?
*Any way you want - concrete floors are very hard to crack.