Jun. 26, 2012: Mortgage jobs; FHA Streamlines & The False Claims Act - 3x damages? Conference call on Basel III for small banks
Rob Chrisman
President
Obama just played his 100th round of golf since being elected
President. In 4 years he has gone through more white tees than
the cast of Jersey Shore. I am not a golfer, but many in the
business are, and people are most focused on a) whether or not
the nation is going to nearly shut down for an entire week, next
week, given the middle-of-the-week 4th holiday, and
b) making sure locked pipelines are closing. Will
lenders close those pipelines and meet delivery timelines for
trades? Were the hedges put on correctly, or will trades have to
be rolled/extended and at what cost? Life in mortgage banking...
And mortgage bankers continue to expand. Freedom Mortgage
Corp. is looking for experienced AE’s in most markets across
the country. Freedom is licensed in all states, has its
FNMA Seller/Servicer & GNMA Servicer/Issuer approvals, and
currently services in excess of $13 billion (retaining servicing
on most of its current production). The lender offers the usual
products to brokers but also the FHA Streamline, VA IRRL, and
HARP loans. If you are interested in talking with Freedom
please contact Keith Bilodeau, who recently joined Freedom as
their VP, as its Director of Recruiting. Keith can be reached
at keith.bilodeau@freedommortgage.com;
Freedom’s website is http://www.freedomwholesale.com.
Today
at 1PM EST investment banker KBW is offering a conference
call to discuss "Proposed Basel III Capital Rules for U.S.
Banks -- How They Affect Regional and Community Banks, and
What Bankers Should Be Doing Now." Basel III doesn’t only
drive down servicing values, which directly impacts borrower’s
rates & prices, and anyone who believes it only impacts the
multi-billion dollar banks is mistaken. "These far-ranging rules
will affect all banks as they are implemented in various stages
over the next ten years. But bankers need to be aware of how
they may affect their industry and their banks, right now,
during the comment period, if there is any hope of molding the
final product. On the call will be five KBW specialists on bank
regulatory issues and research analysts.” It will be followed by
a Q&A session. Dial-In: (888) 212-5201, Passcode: 9343267;
during the call, slides will be made available by following the
link: https://kbw.webex.com/kbw/j.php?ED6361917&UIDI3970087&PWNZDg5ZmY3YzA1&RTMiMxMQ%3D%3D.
More
lenders
& investors, such as Stearns & Nationwide, changed
their FHA Streamline pricing or polices. (See recent
investor/agency/webinar updates below.) Why is this
continuing? The headline from a well-known
investment bank caught my eye: “Enormous Liability Poses Problem
for FHA Lending.” “Several of the mortgagees have publicly
indicated that the moves are being made due to secondary market
conditions or a desire to maintain service to existing
borrowers. But what is really behind the retreat are emerging
government actions and potentially enormous liability in
originating and servicing FHA-insured business – and of course
originators love the product given the low cost to process and
service a streamline refinance. Out of the 237,698 refinance
transactions for $47 billion that FHA has endorsed<http://www.mortgagedaily.com/FhaEndorsements060412.asp>
so far during fiscal-year 2012, around 53 percent have been
streamline transactions.”
The
piece goes on to discuss the “potential liability associated
with originating and servicing FHA mortgages, especially
streamline transactions.” Per Dave Stevens, quoted in the piece,
many FHA mortgagees are being contacted by the HUD Office of
Inspector General about auditing issues, and concerns are
increasing about accusations of False Claims Act violations.
"The real issue here is reps and warrants, risks associated with
originating FHA loans and the huge penalties that are involved
in the FHA program if you make an error," Stevens said. “He
explained that with defects on loans sold to Fannie Mae and
Freddie Mac, the worst-case scenario is repurchase liability or
indemnification. But errors or defects discovered on FHA-insured
loans that go bad where an FHA insurance claim has already been
filed can be considered a violation of the False Claims Act.
‘That means you've filed a claim on a loan that should have
never been insured in the first place and it violates the False
Claims Act,’ Stevens explained. ‘So, the difference here is that
the False Claims Act comes with treble damage risk, meaning you
pay three times the outstanding balance of the loan. Not three
time the net of the loss; three times the outstanding balance of
the loan.’ While the extreme liability applies to both purchase
and refinance transactions, streamline refinances have default
rates that are twice as high as non-streamline transactions --
including fully underwritten refinances. Another problem
outlined by Stevens is the length of time it takes to foreclose
on an FHA loan as a result of the loss mitigation and loss
intervention required by law.”
Speaking
of changes, here are some recent investor/agency/webinar
updates, providing a flavor for the environment. As
always, it is best to read the actual bulletin.
(This is the last darned note on cancelling MI for Freddie
Mac, begun last week. A reader wrote, "To further clarify,
mortgage insurance for a fixed rate mortgage on a one-unit
primary residence can be automatically cancelled based on: 1.
When the mortgage would have been cancelled calculated on the
original value of the mortgaged premises. In other words, the
calculation of 78% LTV is based on the original value of the
mortgaged premises at the time of loan origination, not the
current value of the mortgaged premises – or two – it is when
the midpoint of the amortization period of the mortgage is
reached. To illustrate, if a loan is amortized over 30 years,
and the 360th month is December 2021, the midpoint is the 1st
day of the 180th month, or January 2006. For an Adjustable Rate
Mortgage or a Balloon/Reset Mortgage (either HPA or Pre-HPA),
the above LTV ratio calculation and the midpoint of the
amortization period are both based on the current amortization
schedule following the most recent rate change. Paying down the
mortgage principal will not eliminate the need for MI unless the
current balance is 80% or less of the current value." So what
the reader and the Guide are saying is the same thing: that the
78% is based on the original value and the original
amortization. That is correct. But to pay down the balance to
78% and then cancel based on original value is not permitted.)
“If
you’re going to lead in this industry, learning from a great
leader is a smart move. Register now for tomorrow’s 9AM PST
interactive interview with Jerry Baker. The folks at
Mortgage Coach are bringing in the industry legend to share his
outlook on the road ahead and advice on where you should be
positioning yourself. Be sure to check out Jerry’s top takeaways
from Patrick Lencioni’s brilliant business best-seller ‘The
Advantage.’ To register go to https://www3.gotomeeting.com/register/753503582.
Nationwide
Advantage
Mortgage sent a note to clients, “Due to the
current lending environment NAMC has decided not to purchase FHA
Streamlines at this time. NAMC will honor (underwrite and
purchase) FHA Streamline loans that have been reserved prior to
Monday, June 25, 2012. We will still require compliance with
NAMC overlays with respect to the FHA Streamlines registered
prior to June 25th.”
Stearns
Lending spread the word, “Due to continuing shifts in the
FHA streamline refinance market, the following guideline changes
are being made to minimize risk and remain competitive…effective
with all transactions closed after June 29, 2012: Maximum LTV
limit of 115% will be placed on all streamline refinances
without an appraisal and non-credit qualifying streamline
refinances with appraisal. CLTV/HCLTV will remain at 100% if
there is existing subordinate financing. Value will be confirmed
by an AVM for loans without an appraisal. If an AVM is
inconclusive or is not available, a conventional 2055 will be
required. Employment verification process will not change.
Employer name, address, and phone number must be included on the
1003, income should not be included. A verbal VOE will continue
to be obtained; a 4506T will not be executed. 12 months
ownership history is required for the property being
refinanced.” But with yesterday’s rate sheet Stearns changed
pricing (no longer cumulative) and improved its pricing on FHA
Streamline loans from a flat 1.0% fee plus FICO adds to no fee
and combining the FICO and streamline charges into a tiered FICO
structure.
Pacific
Union
Financial told clients that it “offers FHA
products with limited to no overlays, which allows you to
approve more loans with confidence. Just document and underwrite
in accordance with HUD handbook 4155.1 as amended by any
applicable mortgagee letter and submit them to us…We will
purchase your streamline loans regardless of current servicer,
no credit report required, loans submitted without a credit
report will be priced using a 580 FICO, if a credit report is
submitted, the credit score can be as low as 560 FICO, all
non-credit qualifying streamlines must have a mortgage only
rating, no appraisal or AVM required.”
A
while back GMAC, regarding DU Refi Plus loans,
clarified, “the borrower being removed is also removed from the
deed and retains no ownership interest in the property, and at
least one of the original borrowers is retained on the new
loan.” Condo Requirements: The requirement to confirm fidelity
insurance coverage for condo projects has been removed. Modified
Loans: Permanent Modified loans are eligible for refinance under
DU Refi Plus as long as the borrower benefit is met. The terms
of the permanent, modified loan must be used for this
comparison. If the borrower was previously in a trial period
plan, but denied a permanent modification, the original terms of
the loan must be used. Borrowers who have not completed the
trial period are not eligible. Leasehold Estate Eligibility:
Leasehold review required. Subordinate Financing (The following
applies to all loans): Subordination of existing junior liens
permitted without maximum CLTV/HCLTV limitations. Subordinate
financing repayment terms must be documented by the Note but
review and compliance is not required. There is no restriction
on the type of subordinate financing, excluding Down Payment
Assistance Programs (DPA). DPAs are not eligible.”
SunTrust reminded clients to prepare for Virginia Senate
Bill 409, which amended Section 58.1-803 of the Virginia Code,
effective on July 1, 2012, by eliminating the “same lender”
recordation tax exemption for deeds of trust and mortgages
securing a refinanced obligation and changes the calculation of
the amount of the recordation tax to be paid.
Yesterday in the markets, despite some intra-day volatility,
there was much ado about nothing. The U.S.’s 10-yr T-note is
still in the 1.60’s (closing at 1.61%) after closing Friday at
1.67%. Mortgage-backed security prices improved about .125-.250
– whether or not that improvement made its way onto rate sheets
is unlikely. There are too many companies out there
tampering with profit margins to either slow business down or
cover future overhead costs – and rightfully so.
Today
the economic calendar has the S&P Case Shiller home price
index for April with consensus estimates seen improved +0.3
percent versus +0.1 percent last, and also June’s Consumer
Confidence – estimated to drop. And at 1PM EST the Treasury
holds the first of its three note auctions this week with 2-yr.
notes leading off at $35 billion. (A total of $99 billion will
likely be sold by Thursday after 5yr notes and 7yr notes
complete the monthly sales.) In the early going MBS prices
are nearly unchanged as is the 10-yr at 1.61%.
Here are the “Top 10 things you wish you could say to your
borrowers but can’t.” (Part 2 of 2.)
5. Since you only have $6 worth of verifiable liquid assets, I
will need more of an explanation regarding the four $3,000
non-payroll deposits. Right now, it looks like you are
collecting income from a meth lab in your rental garage.
4. At what point when I was talking about the importance of not
moving money did you decide to pay off $20,000 in student loans?
3. It’s a little less hard to believe these “tax liens” and
“mortgage rates” on your credit report are the “first you are
hearing of this.”
2. It took you three weeks to get me your documents. I will need
a little more than five minutes to get your docs out.
1. No, we don’t really need all of your tax returns – just the
random pages that you feel like sending.
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at www.stratmorgroup.com.
The current blog discusses the issue of the Freddie Mac &
Bank of America buybacks, and its potential impact on the
industry. If you have both the time and inclination, make a
comment on what I have written, or on other comments so that
folks can learn what's going on out there from the other
readers.