|
Jul. 12, 2012: Employment trends; ResCap; HARP chatter; agency updates
Rob Chrisman
Here
at the Western Secondary conference in San Francisco, talk is
focused on investors pushing purchase clearing numbers down
and speeding up purchase times. But anytime you mix two
beautiful young heiresses, big money real estate purchases,
and Formula 1 racing money, it is newsworthy: http://live.wsj.com/video/sisters-spend-150-million-for-two-houses/202CFC67-86BC-4451-885D-2E788A463051.html?modwsj_blog_tboleft#!202CFC67-86BC-4451-885D-2E788A463051.
(Don’t worry – the video ad is short.)
Those
two will never have to worry about working. But lots of folks
do, and Wells Fargo's economic team put out an interesting
piece given the recent employment trends which don’t
seem to be helping the current administration’s reelection
hopes. Men and women have changed over time with respect to
their involvement in the workforce. Male participation is
historically higher, but male participation has been on the
decline for decades. And since the past recession (past?) in
2008, the trajectory of the decline has sharpened. For women,
participation rates had been rising until about 2000, but then
steadied before turning down in 2009. Wells ventures, “The
decline in participation among both men and women present two
challenges for the labor market. First, if there is a loss of
highly skilled workers, like the anecdotes we hear about the
aging engineering and scientific workforce, where are we going to get
replacements? Second, do declining participation rates
mean that potential GDP will be more limited going forward
than in the past?” These issues remind me of what I see as an
issue for mortgage banking and Realtors: who will replace
the aging work population?
PrimeLending’s
President and CEO Todd Salmans was named “CEO of the Year” by
Mortgage Executive Magazine. I have never heard of
Mortgage Executive Magazine, but it was supposedly started
this year by Todd Salmans. Just kidding – a sincere
congratulations to Todd. PrimeLending received the top
honor from Mortgage Executive Magazine’s Top 100
Mortgage Companies in America for 2011. Based on closed
mortgage volume ranking and total units closed, PrimeLending
earned the #1 spot with more than $8.7 billion in loan
volume and more than 45,000 loans in 2011. Word has it that
executives from Wells, Chase, US Bank, and others have left
messages with the staff of the magazine…
Some
folks wonder what the current status of the Fed buying
agency mortgage-backed securities. (By the way, the key
word in that has always been "agency.") The Fed is reinvesting
principal paydowns/prepays from their MBS portfolio. Every
month they publish a forecast of what they expect to buy: http://www.newyorkfed.org/markets/ambs/ambs_faq.html.
The industry continues to watch ResCap's bankruptcy,
even though at this point it is not front page news. The
highly leveraged ResCap subsidiary had made Ally (its parent
company) an unattractive asset because of the fears that the
bank may become responsible for ResCap's debt. On May 15,
2012, Ally put the company into bankruptcy as ResCap had
posted a $402 million loss in 2011 and had missed a $20
million payment on unsecured debt in April. Ally agreed to pay
ResCap $750 million to settle any claims against the parent,
buy as much as $1.6 billion of securities if others don’t, and
provide $150 million to help finance ResCap’s operations
during bankruptcy, according to a company statement. Existing
are various claims that Ally harvested assets from ResCap
before seeking a quick and easy divorce through bankruptcy,
evidenced by the debtors’ plan of separating itself, once and
for all, from ResCap.
But
whether Ally’s agenda also happens to be in the best interest
of ResCap and its creditors is another question. The claim
here is that Ally stripped ResCap of some juicy assets at
below-market prices via "affiliate transactions" prior to
filing. As one report put it, “That would be the equivalent of
someone selling a piece of bank-funded property to their uncle
before walking away from the mortgage. The bank would surely
go after the uncle.” Goldman and Citi faced off during the CDS
auction about the recovery of these unsecured bonds, and the
bonds fell. The 6.5 percent bonds that matured on June 1
dropped more than 7 percent as of yesterday. The 6.5 percent
bonds maturing next year fell 16 percent. And the 6.875
percent bonds fell almost 12 percent. All were selling for
17.6 cents on the dollar. It is unclear if Citi made money on
this transaction, although it looks like the bank (which
coincidentally is also partially US government owned) was more
in the loop than Goldman. GS is now stuck with $345 million in
unsecured bonds (which it bought in the CDS auction) as part
of the game of ResCap musical chairs.
What has been the impact of HARP revisions on loan defaults
and pricing? When the Home Affordable Refinance Program
(HARP) was initiated, its goal was to stimulate the economy
and reducing defaults by lowering mortgage payments in
households with high loan-to-value mortgages. As every LO
knows, these were borrowers who were otherwise unable to
refinance. Refinancing activity was much lower than expected
when HARP was implemented in 2009, and these lackluster
results have reminded us about impediments to refinancing
including credit risk fees, limited lender capacity, a costly
and time consuming appraisal process, limitations on
marketing, and legal risks for lenders. (Is anyone surprised?)
Concerns about revising HARP included doubts about its
fairness efficiency, and it was recently revised. One outcome
of a potentially improved program would be more borrowers in a
position to refinance. The impact of refinancing on future
default risk is important to the current debate of the GSE fee
structure for HARP loans, as these results suggest that
refinancing can be employed as a tool for loss mitigation by
investors and lenders. The optimal refinance fee will be
lower if this reduction in credit losses is recognized.
Reducing fees will increase incentives to refinance but at the
cost of fee income to the GSEs, as the offset to this lower
fee income today is lower credit losses in the future. The
HARP chatter has greatly died down, but the large banks still
account for the majority of the volumes.
Here are some somewhat recent investor/agency updates,
providing a flavor for the environment. They just don’t stop.
As always, it is best to read the actual bulletin.
Fannie
Mae
and Freddie Mac have announced that, as of July
16th, they will not be purchasing or securitizing mortgages
with private transfer fee covenants that were created on or
after February 8, 2011 (certain properties may be exempted due
to FHFA regulation). Such mortgages should be purchased as
whole loans by July 13th at the latest or delivered into MBS
pools with issue dates preceding July 1, 2012.
“Acceptable Conventional Mortgage Insurers and Related
Delivery Codes” and “Special Feature Codes” documents and the
FAQ on the HO-6 and master/blanket insurance requirements on
the Fannie website have been updated, as have the sections on
volume limitations, private transfer fee covenants, and ULDD
terminology in the Selling Guide. The 2000-Character MI Codes
used to identify MI companies in ULDD have been changed as
well, and the ULDD Enumerated Values are now included in what
was previously called the Acceptable Conventional Mortgage
Insurers and MI Codes for Loan Delivery table.
The July 2012 DU Release Notes are now available at
efanniemae.com, and changes pertaining to the VA Bankruptcy
and Foreclosure messaging system, various underwriting issues,
FHA Reserves Calculation on 3-4 unit properties, and the FHA
TOTAL Mortgage Scorecard are scheduled to be made over the
weekend of July 21st.
Fannie
sellers and servicers are encouraged to report key businesses
changes as they occur using the Lender Record Information
application (Form 582), which is the same form used to provide
annual certification. Changes in staffing, principal purpose,
activities, or facilities should be communicated to Fannie as
soon as possible.
Another reminder for servicers: in situations where a
borrower’s mortgage loan modification request was declined on
a date at which the borrower was current, servicers are
required by the Servicing Guide to provide an Adverse Action
Notice.
Additional guidance has been provided on the Uniform Appraisal
Dataset in the form of a resource document with various
updates and reminders on submitting UAD appraisal reports to
the UCDP. UAD Specifications Appendix D (“Field-Specific
Standardization Requirements”) has been revised as well. Both
resources may be found at efanniemae.com, and the GSEs will
continue to issue guidance as necessary.
Fannie has issued a reminder about the “unused” Social
Security Numbers employed in the development of test credit
scores for DO and DU practice cases. Due to changes in the
methodology of assigning SSNs, the test case SSN’s have been
updated. Test credit reports that used the old SSN
information were retired on June 16, 2012; with this in mind,
those who use the test credit report information in their
testing suits should remember to use the new SSNs and Credit
Report Reference Numbers.
A referendum has placed the state of Washington’s decision on
same-sex marriage on hold until November. Registered domestic
partnerships will continue to be recognized.
Wells Fargo Funding reminds sellers that they are
required to comply with the Fair Housing Act, which states
that lenders may not discriminate against borrowers due to a
handicap, when qualifying borrowers with long-term disability
income. The borrower’s condition should not be identified,
either by the borrower or anyone associated with the borrower,
under any circumstance. When qualifying borrowers who receive
Social Security disability benefits, the award letter should
disclose the benefit amount, but the benefits’ continuance
does not need to be verified. Effective immediately for all
government and conventional loans, borrowers with Social
Security Disability Income Award Letters that support their
disability income need not supply any further
documentation. Borrowers seeking a government loan should
not be asked to supply a doctor’s letter with details of the
disability, Social Security Award 1099s, or tax returns to
support the award letter, which satisfies the three-year
income continuance expectation on its own.
Yup,
rates are great. No one is complaining, although Wednesday we
had a little hiccup leading to a few price “worsenings.”
Agency MBS volume was a little stronger than average, which
didn’t help. But traders were more focused on the minutes from
the June Federal Open Market Committee meeting which offered
nothing concrete on Quantitative Easing (QE 3). Basically, the
Fed’s minutes were more hawkish (but also are a bit stale) and
meanwhile appeared to hint that MBS may form a larger part of
any QE3 program (it seems like if there is one signal factor
weighing on equities overnight leading into this morning, it
was disappointment with the tone from the Fed minutes). But
returning to Wednesday, the 10-yr closed at 1.51%.
However,
leading into this morning, overseas banks continue to cut
rates due to the slow economies. Brazil cut rates, Korea cut
rates (an unexpected surprise), and the Bank of Japan
increased its asset purchase program (also a surprise although
they reduced a loan facility so net/net the BOJ isn’t seen as
having eased all that much). Remember that last week the
central banks of China, England, Denmark, and others all eased
rates.
Today
has another moderate calendar of economic news and other
events scheduled. We had Import Prices for June (-2.7%) and
Initial Claims (376k down to 350k – the lowest since March
2008). At 1PM EST the Treasury concludes its latest round of
coupon auctions with $13 billion 30-year bonds. In the
early going the 10-yr is at 1.49% and MBS prices are a shade
better.
(Some things even stump Dear Abby. These are supposedly true
notes - I think some are classics. Part 1 of 2.)
Dear Abby,
A couple of women moved in across the hall from me. One is a
middle-aged gym teacher and the other is a social worker in
her mid-twenties. These two women go everywhere together, and
I've never seen a man go into or leave their apartment. Do
you think they could be Lebanese?
Dear Abby,
What can I do about all the sex, nudity, fowl language, and
violence on my VCR?
Dear Abby,
I have a man I can't trust. He cheats so much, I'm not even
sure the baby I'm carrying is his.
Dear Abby,
I am a twenty-three year old liberated woman who has been on
the pill for two years. It's getting expensive and I think my
boyfriend should share half the cost, but I don't know him
well enough to discuss money with him.
Dear Abby,
I've suspected that my husband has been fooling around, and
when confronted with the evidence, he denied everything and
said it would never happen again.
|