Jul. 20, 2012: Security versus rate sheet prices; big bank earnings & layoffs; eminent domain conference call; good joke on communication
Rob Chrisman
On
Thursday, Fannie 3.5% securities (composed of 3.75-4.125%
30-yr mortgages) traded at a 6 (yes, six) point premium.
Put another way, 106. Fannie 3% securities (with 3.25-3.625%
30-yr mortgages) were above a 3.5 point premium, meaning a 3.5
rebate. But although these securities are very "tight" by any
measuring stick to Treasury yields, no borrower is seeing a
3.5 point rebate on a 3.5% 30-yr conventional loan.
But
we all know that the base MBS price is only one part of
the equation - just like the base price for a car before
extras are added. By the time a rate shows up on the rate
sheet, it has passed through changes due to the base asset
price (MBS), servicing value, buy-ups, buy-downs, mandatory
adjustors, LLPA's, profit margins (at investor and lender
levels), and competition (what is the guy up the street
doing?). And in this environment, lenders have beefed up
those margins to cover rising overhead, reserve against
future litigation and buyback costs, cover the increased
costs of being audited, add capital for servicing, and slow
down production due to capacity issues. Nuff said.
There
are a lot of ways to glean information these days, and I found
this note of interest. "I thought I would send over a copy of
our new eBook (“The world according to HARP (2.0)”) for your
consideration. Our goal is to provide an educational resource
for borrowers. The eBook is available for free download here:
http://blog.westernbancorp.com/landing/harp/.
Thank you to Charles Warnock, Director of Digital Marketing
for Western Bancorp in California. (CEO's, don't be the last
on your block to have a director of digital marketing!)
Speaking
of books, Michele Perrin of Perrin & Associates just wrote
one for “The Lost Bank: The Story of Washington Mutual - The
Biggest Bank Failure in American History” by Kirsten Grind.
(Michele is the former First Vice President of Washington
Mutual's Mortgage Banker Finance Division.) “The book starts
with a prologue from September 25, 2008, the day WaMu was
taken over by the FDIC, but then steps back to 1981 when Lou
Pepper reluctantly finds himself at the helm of unprofitable
$2 billion thrift with 35 branches in Washington State. He
sets about making the place into the "Friend of the Family."
Lou starts coming up with folksy WaMu values for the
employees, like "Ethics, Respect, Teamwork, Innovation &
Excellence," some of which they were still using when Bank
United, where I was working, was acquired by WaMu in 2000. But
sadly for the Bank, by 1986 Lou was nearing retirement age and
must pick a successor. Enter Kerry Killinger…” Let’s not
forget the acquisition of Home Savings, subprime lender Long
Beach Mortgage. In 2003, powered by the Bank's "Higher Risk
Loan Strategy" and the WaMu ad campaign, "The Power of
Yes," the volume of mortgage loans tripled, reaching an
astonishing $155 billion. As much as 80% of WaMu's Option ARMs
were "stated income" loans with no income documentation
(fondly referred to as "Liar Loans"). Perhaps even more
frightening, stated income loans made up 90% of WaMu's home
equity loans. Perhaps JPMorgan Chase didn't get such a bargain
when they bought the Bank from the FDIC for $1.8 billion.
Another
way to gather information is via conference calls. I have
received many e-mails from folks wondering why the eminent
domain issue is a hot button for real estate lending, and
securization in general. Perhaps they should listen in to
SIFMA's call. “San Bernardino County, Fontana and
Ontario CA formed a joint powers authority (JPA) charged with
exploring the use of eminent domain to seize underwater
mortgage loans from their holders, and refinance or otherwise
restructure them. This unprecedented plan, if implemented,
would be significantly disruptive to mortgage markets in San
Bernardino and beyond, due to the material and unjustified
losses it would impose on mortgage-backed security investors,
among others. SIFMA will hold a call today at 11AM EDT to
discuss this issue. Participants can pre-register by clicking
the pre-registration link and entering Conference ID Number:
10016559. A dial-in number will be provided upon completion of
the pre-registration process: https://services.choruscall.com/diamondpass/registration/forwardindex.jsp;jsessionidÈF412525AA05C8D8DCBF5EE31E2AFAB.
Layoffs
at
big banks made the Financial Times headlines today.
“Three of the world’s biggest banks are preparing to shed a
combined 5,350 investment bankers, as the industry struggles
to adapt itself to continuing economic woes and the advent of
new regulation. Morgan Stanley is cutting a further
4,000 jobs, Deutsche Bank is set to lay off about
1,000 of its investment banking staff, equivalent to about 10%
of the unit’s workforce, while Citigroup is shedding
350 bankers. “Analysts believe investment banks will remain
under severe pressure to cut more costs over the coming
months, as the cyclical effects of difficult trading
conditions and a bleak economic outlook add to the longer-term
challenges that come from tougher regulation of the industry.”
So far this year, according to analysts, Morgan Stanley has
implemented 1,600 lay-offs, while UBS, Credit Suisse and
Barclays have all cut 1,500 staff or more.
Last
week we had Chase & Wells earnings. This week we learned
that Bank of America swung to a profit in the second
quarter, earning $2.5 billion. This exceeded analysts’
estimates, but revenue totaled $22.2 billion, slightly less
than expected and below the level in the first quarter this
year. Analysts had been expecting the company to earn $22.9
billion. Credit losses in the second quarter dropped to $1.7
billion from $3.25 billion in the period a year earlier,
reflecting what the company said were improving credit
conditions for businesses and consumers as well as tighter
lending standards. Bank of America plans to cut more than
30,000 workers in the coming years, and the bank has 12,600
fewer employees than it did a year ago. Its Tier 1
capital ratio under the Basel III agreements now stands at 8.1
percent, putting it ahead of the company’s earlier goal of 7.5
percent by the end of 2012. Profit was also bolstered by
so-called reserve releases as $1.9 billion of the $2.5 billion
profit in the second quarter came from reserve releases. Fannie
Mae and Freddie Mac want the company to buy back $11 billion
in bad mortgages, up from $8.1 billion. Meanwhile, private
investors are seeking $8.6 billion in buybacks, up from $4.9
billion.
Elsewhere,
Citigroup’s net income fell 12 percent in the second quarter
partly due to a loss on the sale of its stake in a Turkish
lender. The income of $2.9 billion still exceeded analysts’
expectations, though. The bank reserved $27.6 billion at the
end of the quarter, compared with $34.4 billion in the same
period a year ago. The bank drew down its current loan loss
reserves by $984 million and took an accounting gain of $219
million because the value of its debt decreased. Both of those
items padded earnings. Citi’s retail banking revenues grew
32 percent to $1.6 billion from the second quarter 2011,
largely due to higher mortgage revenues.
Turning
to the markets, there isn’t much to turn to! There has been
very little to talk about in the Eurozone as headlines have
been fairly quiet of late – I guess folks are watching the
Tour de France or are on vacation. Yesterday morning’s Initial
Jobless Claims numbers came in higher/worse than expected, and
the Philly Fed, Existing Home Sales, and Leading Economic
Indicators were also lackluster. (Jobless Claims increased by
34,000 to 386,000 in the week ended July 14 - the volatility
in the numbers was due to a change in the timing of annual
automobile plant layoffs.) Looking at June’s Existing Home
numbers, prices rose again but sales were down. Most of this
was attributed to constrained supply. Existing Homes Sales
declined 5.4% in June to 4.37 million from an upwardly revised
4.62 million in May, but are 4.5% higher than the 4.18
million-unit level in June 2011. The median price of an
existing home increased 7.9% from June 2011 to $189,400, which
reflects an increase in the purchase of higher-priced
properties. At the current pace, it would take 6.6 months to
sell existing inventory, the longest since November, compared
with 6.4 months at the end of the prior period.
Analysts
suggest that consumer spending is sputtering, manufacturing
growth has slowed, and businesses have grown cautious about
investment. But housing is doing pretty well. Cutbacks on home
construction shaved as much as a full percentage point from
GDP during the darkest days of 2007 and 2008. This year,
construction should turn positive—adding around 0.3% points to
GDP. By the close on Thursday, 10-year T-notes closed
down/worse by about .250 (1.51%), and MBS prices worsened by
about .125.
But
overnight and today Asian equity markets finished mostly
lower, in Europe equities are selling off 0.5% in the
aggregate, and it appears our stock markets will be down –
economies just aren’t doing that well. In Europe, Spain's
10-year yield has breached the 7% level that tipped Greece,
Ireland, and Portugal into IMF/EU bailouts. Here in the U.S
today and Monday have nothing for news scheduled. The
10-yr is down to 1.48% and MBS prices are better by about
.125.
Corporate game of telephone: “Eclipse Memos.”
Memo from Owner to the CEO:
Today at 11 o'clock there will be a total eclipse of the sun.
This is when the sun disappears behind the moon for two
minutes. As this is something that cannot be seen every day,
time will be allowed for employees to view the eclipse in the
parking lot. Staff should meet in the parking lot at ten to
eleven, when I will deliver a short speech introducing the
eclipse, and giving some background information. Safety
goggles will be made available at a small cost.
Memo from CEO to the Head of Operations:
Today at ten to eleven, all staff should meet in the parking
lot. This will be followed by a total eclipse of the sun,
which will disappear for two minutes. For a moderate cost,
this will be made safe with goggles. The Owner will deliver a
short speech beforehand to give us all some background
information. This is not something that can be seen every day.
Memo from the Head of Operations to the Head of Underwriting:
The Owner will today deliver a short speech to make the sun
disappear for two minutes in the eclipse. This is something
that cannot be seen every day, so staff will meet in the
parking lot at ten or eleven. This will be safe, if you pay a
moderate cost.
Memo from the Head of Underwriting to the Underwriting Team
Supervisor:
Ten or eleven staff are to go to the parking lot, where the
Owner will eclipse the sun for two minutes. This doesn't
happen every day. It will be safe, but it will cost you.
Memo from the Underwriting Team Supervisor to the
underwriters:
Some staff will go to the parking lot today to see the Owner
disappear. It is a pity this doesn't happen every day.