Aug. 15, 2012: Chicago eminent domain update; "when" not "if" for buybacks; lots of CFPB servicing proposal info; CFPB's undercover sleuth program hiring
Rob Chrisman
Yesterday
afternoon, per the Census Bureau, the U.S. population reached
a milestone that is very meaningful to mathematicians:
314,159,265 residents, or pi (3.14159265) times 100 million.
Pi is a mathematical constant that is the ratio of a circle’s
circumference to its diameter. “This is a once in many
generations event...so go out and celebrate this American pi,”
said Census Bureau Chief Demographer Howard Hogan. The
securitization industry had a little something to celebrate
yesterday, and that was Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel's position
on eminent domain: http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/breaking/chi-emanuel-eminent-domain-not-the-right-instrument-to-address-underwater-mortgages-20120814,0,575221.story.
In
the story above is a brief explanation on how Mortgage
Resolution Partners stands to profit from their efforts.
A note I received yesterday observed, “This excerpt from the
Mortgage Resolution Partners website says a lot: ‘Implementation of the
CARES program by local governments acts as a catalyst for
similar programs in other communities and for broader policy
changes, helping to alleviate the US mortgage crisis.’
Maybe attorneys and special interest groups could alleviate
all mortgages - that would end the crisis.”
A
quick clarification. Yesterday's banter about Realtors and
LO's contained a link to NAR’s regulatory efforts. But as many
folks pointed out, that link isn’t redirecting correctly since
it’s going to an internal, “member section” of NAR's site.
Here is the appropriate link to see what the organization has
been up to: http://www.realtor.org/political-advocacy/all-advocacy-issues.
And
anyone who thinks that buybacks issues are behind us had
better think twice. "Fannie & Freddie Continuing to
Clamp Down on Banks" is the trend, and trust me, given
that banks are not likely to absorb all this by themselves,
these putbacks will be pushed down into smaller originators: http://in.reuters.com/article/2012/08/14/us-mortgages-repurchases-idINBRE87D14V20120814.
I
was reading in the paper today about this dwarf that got
pick-pocketed. How could anyone stoop so low? Many in the
industry are accusing the CFPB of stooping low by
advertising that it wants employees to go "undercover",
a la secret shoppers, to nab banks. Use the code name
"George Orwell." Here is the complete story: http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/aug/12/consumer-bureau-seeks-sleuths-for-bad-bankers/print/.
Many
in the industry are concerned about the CFPB's proposed
mortgage servicing rules. The proposals consist of a
250-page Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201208_cfpb_respa_proposed_rules.pdf)
(Regulation X) rule and a 178-page Truth in Lending Act
(Regulation Z) rule (http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201208_cfpb_tila_proposed_rules.pdf).
Comments
on the proposals will be due by October 9; implementation is
expected to be issued by January. While the proposals’ page
count may seem modest compared to the CFPB’s nearly 1,100 page
proposal integrating RESPA/TILA disclosures, the servicing
proposals are untypically single-spaced rather than
double-spaced.
There
is a short, readable write up of its implications at http://www.stratmorgroup.com/,
click on the link in the top right corner. Note that both
Fitch Ratings and the MBA have reacted to the CFPB’s
proposed rules for mortgage servicers. Fitch said that
in general it views the proposed rules positively because, if
implemented, they would set consistent standards for all
servicers, including smaller nonbank entities "that have thus
far avoided the mandated changes." Fitch, however, warned
that the rules, like other servicing focused initiatives, will
further increase compliance costs.
Let’s
move on to some relatively recent agency, investor, and
vendor updates. They just don’t stop – I don’t know how
underwriters keep track of them! For full details it is best
to read the full bulletin, but these will give you a flavor
for what is going on.
As part of the revision of policies on continuance of income
verification, Fannie Mae has added guidelines about
evaluating variable income (hourly pay, overtime, bonuses,
commission) to address history of receipt, frequency of
payment, and income trending. Clarification has been issued
regarding types of income that require the lender to verify a
three-year continuance and income sources that have a defined
expiration date or that are based on the depletion of an
asset. Lenders are now required to supply federal income tax
returns to confirm income from temporary or periodic
employment, interest and dividends, and any business in which
the borrower has a stake of at least 25%.
Fannie will be adjusting the required interest rate for
standard modifications with a pre-modification mark-to-market
LTV ratio of 80% or more. This rate is required to be
implemented for standard modifications with Trial Period plans
that go into effect on or after September 1, 2012, though
servicers are encouraged to do so for Trial Period plans that
go into effect on or after August 1st.
HUD has made a few changes to the TOTAL Scorecard, the
new version of which should be used for all first-time risk
assessments after July 21st. Any applications that were
scored with a case number under the previous edition of the
Scorecard will be eligible to be re-scored under the previous
edition for 90 days, after which they will be subject to the
new one. The revisions include the addition of review rules
and error codes and the changing of some optional data fields
to required data fields; the full details of the changes may
be viewed at http://www.hud.gov/pub/chums/aus-developers-guide.pdf.
As the FHA prepares to update the process used to
remit MI premiums for the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage
program, it is requiring all FHA-approved mortgagees
currently responsible for remitting MI premiums but not
involved with the Home Equity Reverse Mortgage Information
Technology project to submit certain information by July
25th. The company name; 10-digit FHA Mortgagee ID number;
name and title of the company representatives who oversee HECM
origination, servicing, and claims; and the phone numbers and
email addresses of each company representative should be
emailed to HERMITUAM@hud.gov.
Most everyone knows that the Disputed Credit and Identity of
Interest sections of FHA Mortgagee Letter 2012-10, which were
scheduled to become effective on July 1st, have been
rescinded. The guidance on Year-to-Date P&L and Balance
Sheets and Identity of Interest remains in effect for all case
numbers assigned on or after April 1, 2012.
Flagstar has issued additional guidance following its
earlier announcement that any FHA Streamline refinances
registered on or after July 6th where Flagstar wasn’t the
original loan’s servicer would be subject to a requirement of
a FICO score of at least 680 and a loan level pricing
adjustment. Loans that were underwritten by Flagstar,
registered on or before July 5th, and currently floating are
exempt from the new conditions provided that they are funded
and disbursed by July 31st, while locked loans remain exempt
if they’re funded and disbursed by July 31st or the lock
expiration date, whichever is later. Such loans will not be
granted lock extensions and will be re-priced if the deadlines
are not met. Similar guidelines apply to floating FHA DE
Delegated Correspondent loans, which, given that they were
registered before July 5th and meet the July 31st deadline for
delivery, are excepted. FHA DE Delegated Correspondent loans
that have already locked should be delivered by the later of
July 31st or within five business days of the lock expiring to
remain exempt.
The Fannie DU Refi Plus II program at Flagstar has been
updated such that it is now divided into “Fannie Mae DU Refi
Plus II—Same Servicer” and “Fannie Mae DU Refi Plus II—Other
Servicer,” which represent two separate sets of products. The
eligibility requirements for the former remain unchanged;
however, guidelines for the latter have been amended. Loans
under “Fannie Mae DU Refi Plus II—Other Servicer” will be
subject to their own set of LTV and FICO score guidelines
depending on the property type, a DTI limit of 40%, and a
requirement of a minimum of six months’ verified reserves, for
which all large deposits much be accounted. Any loans that
receive an “Expanded Approval” response require a DU Property
Fieldwork Waiver, without which they are not eligible. With
regards to pricing, loans under the “Other Servicer” program
that have EA risk classes are subject to updated EA price
adjustments, while the EA adjustment for “Same Servicer”
products remains at -0.25 for all EA levels. Loans currently
in the pipeline under the existing Fannie Mae DU Refi Plus II
program need to be locked on or before July 26th; failure to
do so will require the loan to be switched to one of the new
products.
With regards to loans initially targeted to Wells Fargo,
Flagstar has announced that it will accept such loans provided
that they fit within the current guidelines. AIR compliant
appraisals from Wells will be accepted so long as they are
accompanied by an AIR compliance certificate and a lender
letter from Wells. Appraisals completed by an appraiser on
the Flagstar Ineligible Appraiser list will require a new
appraisal to be ordered.
As per the recently issued FHA regulation, Flagstar will no
longer purchase any transaction where the property is
encumbered by private transfer fee covenants. This applies to
pipeline loans and new registrations both.
Genworth’s
US Mortgage Insurance division has integrated a new “Quick
Submit” option into its customer-facing website that allows
users to submit full-service loan packages and receive an MI
coverage decision with increased ease. Much of the redundant
data entry required under the old interface is no longer
necessary, and contract underwriting, HARP, and “doc-only”
full-package loans can all be submitted under a single
username and password. Users are also able to track the
status of loans they submit.
Yesterday the fixed income (bond) market reacted to the strong
Retail Sales stats – is the U.S. economy really picking up
steam? Perhaps – certainly property values aren’t plunging,
the job market is not desperate, and many government
statistics point to areas of improvement. But both stocks and
bonds sank in price, so not everyone is convinced. And as we
know, low rates can only help mortgage applications for so
long (“refi fatigue”), and the MBA’s survey reported
that last week’s home loan applications dropped 4.5%. The
refinance index decreased 5% from the previous week, and
purchases were down 2%. Refi’s are still strong: 81% of total
apps, much of that from banks. (ARM’s are still down around
4%.) The average conforming rate was 3.76% and the average
jumbo rate was 4.03% - so there you go: .25% difference. (The
vast majority of jumbo loans are sitting in bank portfolios –
and why not given those rates?)
This
morning risk-free Treasury prices are pointing lower again
today to a nearly three month high in yield on the 10-yr at
1.76% (it hit 1.79% in London overnight). But stocks are
pointing lower – wassup with that? The smartest minds in the
room seem to think that the US economy is growing enough for
the Federal Reserve to avoid further stimulus measures, but
not enough to really help companies (and therefore stock
prices). Of course this outlook could, and will, change. For
concrete news, we had the Consumer Price Index this morning.
Expected at +.2% for July, it was unchanged, with the core
rate only up .1% - both more moderate than expected. The
Empire Manufacturing Index was down 5.85. In the early
going the 10-yr is around 1.77%, and agency MBS prices are
worse about .250.
(Parental discretion advised!)
Here are some rumored “top” comments made by sports
commentators during Summer Olympics:
1. Dressage commentator: "This is really a lovely horse and I
speak from personal experience since I once mounted her
mother."
2. Paul Hamm, Gymnast: "I owe a lot to my parents, especially
my mother and father."
3. Boxing Analyst: "Sure there have been injuries and even
some deaths in boxing, but none of them really that serious."
4. Softball announcer: "If history repeats itself, I should
think we can expect the same thing again."
5. Basketball analyst: "He dribbles a lot and the opposition
doesn't like it. In fact you can see it all over their faces."
6. At the rowing medal ceremony: "Ah, isn't that nice, the
wife of the IOC president is hugging the cox of the British
crew."
7. Soccer commentator: "Julian Dicks is everywhere. It's like
they've got eleven Dicks on the field."
8. Tennis commentator: "One of the reasons Andy is playing so
well is that, before the final round, his wife takes out his
balls and kisses them... Oh my God, what have I just said?"
If
you're interested, visit my twice-a-month blog at the STRATMOR
Group web site located at www.stratmorgroup.com.
The current blog discusses the CFPB’s servicing proposals, for
better or worse. If you have both the time and
inclination, make a comment on what I have written, or on
other comments so that folks can learn what's going on out
there from the other readers.