|
Sep. 27, 2012: Basel III to help big banks? And a calculation tool to show its impact; Texas Ratio helps LO's think about bank health
Rob Chrisman
Even
though last Saturday was the equinox, here's the weird thing:
five days after the equinox today is the "longest" day of the
year! If you're thinking about the sun and the earth, or time,
you're barking up the wrong tree...just like statistics, and
ways of reducing the deficit, there are different ways of
looking at the same thing. In this case, there are a lot of
ways to measure how long things are. "Thursday September
twenty-seventh" is the longest day of the year! The longest
in terms of text, that is: Thursday September twenty-seventh.
Give that one to your kids!
As
California goes, so goes the nation? We'll see, but Governor
Brown signed into law several mortgage-related bills:
http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-mortgage-brown-20120926,0,1843070.story.
I
am sitting here wearing my Countrywide golf shirt, drinking
out of my Long Beach mug, my mouse sitting on my WAMU mouse
pad, a little yellow Greenpoint duck somewhere in the drawer.
(My Taylor Bean & Whittaker bourbon is hidden, otherwise
my dog gets into it.) And now my Smith Barney t-shirt has made
the cut! Morgan Stanley has officially dropped the Smith
Barney name from its wealth management business, making
the former Citigroup brokerage the latest name casualty.
Morgan Stanley Smith Barney (kind of like that Bank of America
Merrill Lynch name that is still with us) has 17,000 financial
advisers in 740 locations, will now be known as “Morgan
Stanley Wealth Management.” Smith Barney's been around since
the 1800's - a little longer than Household Finance (pencil
holder) or First Magnus (cap).
"I
am
hearing that what LO's are busy with is refinancing folks
they refinanced 6 months ago. True?" You bet it is true.
Lots of folks that didn't qualify then don't qualify now, thus
the hope for property values to increase so that equity can
increase, slowly expanding the pool of eligible borrowers
to...refinance. Rates are certainly cooperating. QE3 gave the
mortgage market a shot in the arm as $40B per month in Fed
purchases has helped to boost MBS prices. However, this policy
change, in addition to others, is certainly creating some turmoil
in the "specified pool" market. (That is the market
where the agencies or aggregators slice and dice pools of
loans, assembling groups of loans with certain characteristics
that investors "specify" and for which they'll pay a higher
price.) Higher prices/lower rates will likely increase prepay
speeds but the immensity of Fed buying can also cause
heartburn. When the Fed targets a coupon for purchases, paper
can become scarce and this typically results in higher roll
costs if a security hedge isn't filled and has to be moved to
the next month. The higher cost or "specialness" of the roll
translates into MBS becoming more expensive to use as a hedge.
Consequently, traders, who typically use TBA trades to hedge
their position, are being forced to consider other
alternatives, including treasuries and swaps.
Why should anyone care about any of this? Specified pay-ups
for these coupons will be lower. Pools of conventional loans
of less than $85k, for example, were priced higher than
"normal" production by 1.5 points at one point. Now, however,
$85k max Fannie 30-yr 3.5's are now "only" 1.25 better.
Meanwhile, Fannie and Freddie's recently announced an increase
in guaranty fees will likely have the inverse impact of QE3
and will be passed along to borrowers in the form of higher
costs/rates, thus slowing speeds. How’s a Capital Markets guy
supposed to keep up?
While the industry deals with QE Unlimited volatility, now
is not the time to forget Basel III and its proposed
restrictions on servicing and capital. The OCC and FDIC
announced the availability of a regulatory capital
estimation tool to help community banking organizations
and other interested parties evaluate recently published
regulatory capital proposals. The tool will assist these
organizations in estimating the potential effects on their
capital ratios of the agencies’ Basel III Notice of Proposed
Rulemaking (NPR) and Standardized Approach NPR. By the way,
the comment period on current regulatory capital standards
ends on October 22. The Basel III NPR focuses primarily on
strengthening the level of regulatory capital requirements and
improving the quality of capital. The Standardized Approach
NPR proposes a number of enhancements to the risk-sensitivity
of the agencies’ capital standards. The tool is intended to
help institutions estimate the potential effect the proposals
could have on their capital ratios. It should not be relied
on as an indicator of an institution’s actual regulatory
capital ratios and is not part of the NPRs nor of any final
rule(s) that the agencies may adopt. The estimation tools are
available for banks, savings associations and their holding
companies at: http://www.fdic.gov/regulations/capital/calculator.html.
And if you just can't get enough, here is the link to the
Basel III NPR: http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2012-08-30/pdf/2012-16757.pdf
and the Standardized Approach NPR: http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2012-08-30/pdf/2012-17010.pdf
A story in the Financial Times reports, “Rules aimed at
curbing financial sector excess could drive more business
to the biggest banks and make it even more difficult to
allow the world’s largest lenders to fail, the International
Monetary Fund has warned. The IMF argued in a paper released
on Tuesday that the Basel III rules – global regulators’
response to the financial crisis – would exacerbate the
too-big-to-fail problem, where governments were forced to
rescue financial institutions deemed so large, or
interconnected, that their collapse would wreak havoc on the
entire financial system.” “Big banking groups with advantages
of scale may be better able to absorb the costs of the
regulations; as a result, they may become even more prominent
in certain markets, making these markets more concentrated,”
IMF analysts wrote in the chapter of its latest Global
Financial Stability Report. The IMF cautioned that the
rules were also raising the incentives to develop new
products to circumvent the framework. There was also a
‘high chance’ that the framework would push riskier activity
into less regulated parts of the financial system.” Has anyone
seen my SISA rate sheet?
"I
am a retail LO in Georgia, thinking about throwing in the
towel and going to work for a bank. A bank has offered me a
spot, but then a friend told me that the bank's 'Texas
Ratio' is above 100. Does that matter for a lowly LO?"
Sure it does. The Texas ratio is a measure of a bank's credit
troubles: the higher the Texas ratio, the more severe the
credit troubles. The actual ratio is calculated by dividing
the value of the lender's non-performing assets
(Non-performing loans + Real Estate Owned) by the sum of its
tangible common equity capital and loan loss reserves. The
history of recent bank failures suggests that any bank above
100 has a much higher probability of closing down. Per Pacific
Coast Bankers, there are “248 banks remaining with a TR
greater than 100% scattered across 39 different states.
Overall, given there were 6,639 institutions (“banks”) in the
country, this group represents about 3.7% of the total. That
is a strong improvement from the peak when it was much higher.
Broken down by state, GA still has the most strained banks by
this measure at 49, followed by IL (31) and FL (30). Taken as
a group, these three states alone represent about 44% of all
the troubled banks in the country.” At this point, of all of
Georgia’s banks, 21% of them are strained with a TR of 100% or
more, followed by Washington DC with 20%. For a list and more
information visit http://www.depositaccounts.com/banks/health.aspx.
The
M&A,
MI, and investor updates have been a deluge in September.
As always, it is best to read the actual bulletin, and “good
luck” if you’re looking for less documentation, lower net
worth requirements, or easier processing.
Bank
mergers continue. In the Pacific Northwest, Columbia
Banking System and West Coast Bancorp (both are publicly
held) jointly announced that the companies have agreed to
combine their two leading Pacific Northwest community bank
franchises in a transaction valued at approximately $506
million. The combined company will have approximately $7.2
billion in assets with over 150 branches throughout Washington
and Oregon and will rank number 1 in deposit market share
amongst commercial community banks in the combined states of
Washington and Oregon.
“Republic Mortgage Insurance Company ("RMIC") has
received a Notice of Hearing from the North Carolina
Department of Insurance ("NCDOI"). The Hearing is scheduled
for October 16, 2012, and its purpose is to enable the NCDOI
and stakeholders to consider a revised Corrective Plan ("the
Plan") submitted by RMIC on September 14, 2012, as required by
the NCDOI Commissioner's Summary Order ("the Order") dated
January 19, 2012. The Notice of Hearing and related
information has been posted on the Company's website at
|